x.com/cjhandmer/status/2109279208921047296?s=46&t=fSypFxt84bBHId-do9r5Ag
1 correction found
For structural reasons it's essentially impossible to change published work, even to correct a typo.
Published papers are routinely corrected after publication through formal errata/correction processes. Major publishers and COPE explicitly provide mechanisms for post-publication corrections, including typo corrections in some cases.
Full reasoning
Major scholarly publishers do not treat post-publication correction as "essentially impossible." They have formal, documented processes for correcting published work.
- Wiley states that providing a process to correct a published article is a "core practice" of an ethical journal office, and says: "If there is an error to be corrected after an article has published in an issue, we publish a correction that will link to the original article."
- Springer Nature's support documentation says that if an error is found in a published article — including "typos" — authors should contact the publisher and request a formal correction.
- Nature/Springer also publish many concrete correction notices for typographical errors. For example, Scientific Reports published a correction stating: "The original HTML version of this Article contained a typographical error in Equation 1 ... This error has now been corrected in the HTML version." Another Nature correction says: "Finally, a minor typographical error was corrected in the Abstract. The Article has been corrected online."
So while publishers often preserve the version-of-record by documenting changes through linked correction notices rather than silently rewriting history, it is inaccurate to say correcting published work is "essentially impossible," or that even a typo cannot be corrected. Formal corrections and typo corrections are a standard part of scholarly publishing.
4 sources
- Managing Corrections to Published Articles
This is why the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) considers providing a process to correct a published article to be a core practice of an ethical journal editorial office... If there is an error to be corrected after an article has published in an issue, we publish a correction that will link to the original article.
- Post-publication journal corrections : Springer Nature Support
If an error is found in a published article (typos, author details, affiliations, or scientific corrections), please contact us... changes that are made post-publication must be made through a formal correction process and may not always be possible.
- Publisher Correction: Temporal rate is not a distinct perceptual metric | Scientific Reports
The original HTML version of this Article contained a typographical error in Equation 1... This error has now been corrected in the HTML version; the PDF version was correct from the time of publication.
- Publisher Correction: Butterfly effect and a self-modulating El Niño response to global warming | Nature
Finally, a minor typographical error was corrected in the Abstract. The Article has been corrected online.