en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Innocent_X
4 corrections found
who had come to Rome during the pontificate of Pope Innocent IX
The Pamphilj family was in Rome well before Innocent IX; sources place its move in the late 15th century and connect its rise to Innocent VIII, not Innocent IX.
Full reasoning
This is a chronology error. Innocent IX reigned only in 1591, but the Pamphilj family’s Roman branch was established much earlier.
- Treccani says the Roman branch began when Antonio Pamphili entered the Curia in the second half of the 15th century, obtained the office of procuratore fiscale in 1460, and settled in Piazza Pasquino in 1479.
- A Cambridge University Press article states that "A branch of the family transferred to Rome during the reign of Sixtus IV (1471-84), whose successor, Innocent VIII (1484-92), promoted Andrea Pamphilj" and adds that Innocent X’s papal name acknowledged the family’s rise under Innocent VIII.
So the family did not come to Rome during the pontificate of Innocent IX.
2 sources
- INNOCENZO X, papa - Treccani
Il capostipite del ramo romano, Antonio, entrò in Curia nella seconda metà del XV secolo e il 10 nov. 1460 ottenne la carica di procuratore fiscale della Camera apostolica. Nel 1479 si stabilì in piazza Pasquino...
- Antiquarianism and the Villa Pamphilj on the Janiculum Hill in Rome
A branch of the family transferred to Rome during the reign of Sixtus IV (1471-84), whose successor, Innocent VIII (1484-92), promoted Andrea Pamphilj... The name Giovan Battista Pamphilj took as pope in 1644 acknowledged his family's elevation in Roman affairs under Innocent VIII.
In 1623 Pope Gregory XV sent him as apostolic nuncio
Pamphilj was appointed nuncio to Naples in 1621, not 1623.
Full reasoning
The appointment date here is off by about two years.
- Treccani states that after Gregory XV became pope in February 1621, "Il 26 marzo con un breve fu nominato nunzio a Napoli" — he was appointed nuncio to Naples on 26 March 1621.
- Catholic-Hierarchy likewise lists him as appointed Apostolic Nuncio to Naples on 26 Mar 1621.
- The Doria Pamphilj family biography also says he served as Papal Nuncio to Naples from March 1621 to March 1625.
So 1623 is incorrect; the correct year is 1621.
3 sources
- INNOCENZO X, papa - Treccani
L'ascesa al soglio pontificio di Alessandro Ludovisi (Gregorio XV), il 9 febbr. 1621, segnò una nuova tappa nella sua carriera. Il 26 marzo con un breve fu nominato nunzio a Napoli.
- Pope Innocent X (Giovanni Battista Pamphilj) - Catholic-Hierarchy
26 Mar 1621 ... Appointed Apostolic Nuncio to Naples, Italy.
- Biographies Rome - Doria Pamphilj
From March 1621 to March 1625 he was Papal Nuncio to Naples and legate to France and Spain...
whom he had accredited as nuncio
Francesco Barberini was sent as papal legate, not as nuncio.
Full reasoning
This misstates Francesco Barberini’s diplomatic role. Contemporary scholarship and modern reference works describe Barberini’s 1625–1626 missions as a legation, not a nunciature.
- Treccani says Urban VIII recalled Pamphilj in March 1625 to assign him to the service of Cardinal Francesco Barberini, who had been "nominato legato a latere in Francia"; it then says Barberini was again "nominato legato a latere in Spagna" in 1626.
- A scholarly study on papal finances and diplomacy is explicitly titled "le cas de la légation du cardinal Francesco Barberini en France en 1625".
- Another scholarly study on Pamphilj’s Spanish correspondence says he accompanied Francesco Barberini "nella sua legazione in Francia e in Spagna" as datary.
So Barberini was acting as a papal legate, not a nuncio.
3 sources
- INNOCENZO X, papa - Treccani
...il cardinale Francesco Barberini, nominato legato a latere in Francia... ...a fianco di F. Barberini, nominato legato a latere in Spagna.
- Finances pontificales et représentation diplomatique du Saint-Siège au temps d'Urbain VIII : le cas de la légation du cardinal Francesco Barberini en France en 1625
...le cas de la légation du cardinal Francesco Barberini en France en 1625...
- La corrispondenza del nunzio Giovanni Battista Pamphilj e le relazioni con la Spagna nella prima metà del XVII secolo
...fu richiamato alla corte di Roma per accompagnare, in qualità di datario, il cardinale Francesco Barberini nella sua legazione in Francia e in Spagna.
graduated from the Collegio Romano
Pamphilj’s degree was from the University of Rome La Sapienza, not the Collegio Romano.
Full reasoning
This identifies the wrong institution. Treccani’s biographical entry says Giovanni Battista Pamphilj earned his doctorate in civil and canon law at the Sapienza of Rome. A modern biographical page associated with Palazzo Pamphilj likewise states that he graduated in law from the University of Sapienza in 1594.
The Collegio Romano and La Sapienza were different institutions, so saying he graduated from the Collegio Romano is inaccurate.
2 sources
- INNOCENZO X, papa - Treccani
Addottoratosi in utroque iure alla Sapienza di Roma, il Pamphili fu avvocato nella cerchia dello zio...
- Pope Innocent X - Eitch Borromini
Graduated in law from the University of Sapienza in 1594...