www.lesswrong.com/posts/HJNtrNHf688FoHsHM/guide-to-rationalist-interior-decorati...
2 corrections found
CRI only applies to buying LEDs
CRI is not an LED-only metric. It is a general color-rendering measure used for many light sources, including fluorescent and incandescent lamps.
Full reasoning
This is too narrow: CRI does not apply only to LEDs.
The U.S. Department of Energy defines the Color Rendering Index (CRI) generally as a scale that measures a light source’s ability to render colors the way sunlight does. That definition is not limited to LED products.
Federal law and federal test procedures also show CRI being used for non-LED lamps:
- The U.S. Code defines a category of fluorescent lamps by whether they have a color rendering index of 87 or greater.
- DOE test procedures explicitly include methods for measuring CRI for incandescent lamps.
So while it is true that incandescent lamps are typically around CRI 100, the statement that CRI “only applies to buying LEDs” is incorrect. CRI is a broader lighting metric used across multiple lamp technologies.
3 sources
- Lighting Principles and Terms | Department of Energy
The Color Rendering Index (CRI) is a 1-100 scale that measures a light source's ability to render colors the same way sunlight does.
- 42 U.S. Code § 6291 - Definitions | Legal Information Institute
The term "general service fluorescent lamp" ... does not include ... Lamps with a color rendering index of 87 or greater.
- Energy Conservation Program: Test Procedures for General Service Fluorescent Lamps, Incandescent Reflector Lamps, and General Service Incandescent Lamps
DOE is adopting amendments ... [to] provide test methods for measuring coloring rendering index (CRI) for incandescent lamps.
companies aren’t allowed to produce incandescents anymore
That overstates the U.S. rules on incandescent bulbs. Many general-service incandescent bulbs were phased out, but numerous incandescent categories remained legal and explicitly exempt.
Full reasoning
This claim is too broad.
U.S. efficiency rules did not mean that companies were categorically forbidden to make all incandescent bulbs. Even after the 2023 phaseout of many inefficient general-service incandescent bulbs, federal law and DOE guidance still recognized multiple exempt incandescent categories.
DOE’s own myth-busting page says the U.S. government is not banning all lightbulbs and that specialized incandescent bulbs remain exempt. The underlying statute likewise lists many excluded incandescent categories, including appliance lamps, bug lamps, reflector lamps, 3-way incandescent lamps, vibration-service lamps, and several decorative bulb shapes.
So the accurate version would be something like: many common general-service incandescent bulbs were being phased out, but incandescent bulbs were not banned across the board.
2 sources
- Debunking Myths about Phasing Out the Incandescent Lightbulb | Department of Energy
Reality: The US government is not banning all lightbulbs... Specialized incandescent bulbs - like bug lights and those that go inside ovens - are exempt from this new rule.
- 42 U.S. Code § 6291 - Definitions | Legal Information Institute
The term "general service incandescent lamp" does not include the following incandescent lamps... An appliance lamp... A bug lamp... A reflector lamp... A 3-way incandescent lamp... A vibration service lamp... [and] A B, BA, CA, F, G16-1/2, G-25, G30, S, or M-14 lamp... of 40 watts or less.