itsnotgambling.substack.com/p/representative-futarchy
1 correction found
So a new concept was born: representatives.
Rome did not solve this by creating a representative legislature; Roman citizens still voted directly in assemblies, and Britannica notes that electing representatives was a solution that came ‘two millennia later.’
Full reasoning
This misdescribes how the Roman Republic worked. Romans did not respond to scale by inventing a representative legislature of the modern kind.
Britannica explicitly says that because Roman assemblies kept meeting in Rome, most citizens outside the city were effectively excluded, and that “Two millennia later, the solution—electing representatives to a Roman legislature—would seem obvious.” In other words, representative government was not the Roman solution.
Britannica’s article on the Roman assemblies further states that during the Republic, two different assemblies elected magistrates, exercised legislative power, and made other important decisions, and that only adult male Roman citizens could attend the assemblies in Rome and exercise the right to vote. That is direct citizen voting in assemblies, not government by representatives acting in citizens’ place.
So the problem of distance and scale in Rome was real, but the specific claim that this produced the new concept of political representatives is historically wrong.
3 sources
- Democracy - Roman Republic, Representation, Equality | Britannica
Because Roman assemblies continued to meet in the Forum... most citizens who did not live in or near the city itself were unable to participate... Two millennia later, the solution—electing representatives to a Roman legislature—would seem obvious.
- Ancient Rome - Senate, Republic, Empire | Britannica
During the republic two different assemblies elected magistrates, exercised legislative power, and made other important decisions. Only adult male Roman citizens could attend the assemblies in Rome and exercise the right to vote.
- Comitia Centuriata | Roman Republic, Centuriate Assembly, Voting | Britannica
Comitia Centuriata... decided on war and peace, passed laws, elected consuls, praetors, and censors.