en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samurai
3 corrections found
In 1871, the government banned the samurai topknot (the chonmage).
The 1871 Danpatsu Dattōrei did not ban the topknot. It made haircutting optional/allowed and encouraged it, rather than prohibiting the hairstyle outright.
Full reasoning
The 1871 Danpatsu Dattōrei (散髪脱刀令) is commonly described in primary and library-reference sources as a measure that permitted men to cut their hair and abandon sword-wearing, not as a ban on the samurai topknot.
The National Archives of Japan explains that in Meiji 4 (1871) the government proclaimed: "散髪、制服、略服、礼服ノ外、脱刀モ自今勝手タルベシ" and summarizes this as allowing men to go without a topknot and allowing even shizoku/samurai-status people not to wear swords. In other words, it recognized freedom of hairstyle and dress rather than outlawing the topknot.
The National Diet Library's collaborative reference database likewise states that in August 1871 the government issued the 散髪脱刀令, permitted haircutting, and encouraged it. That directly contradicts the claim that the government "banned" the samurai topknot in 1871.
So the historically accurate point is that the 1871 edict allowed and promoted haircutting; it did not itself impose a nationwide legal ban on the chonmage.
2 sources
- あの日の公文書 | 国立公文書館ニュース Vol.13
明治4年(1871)には、明治政府が太政官布告により『散髪、制服、略服、礼服ノ外、脱刀モ自今勝手タルベシ』という『散髪脱刀令』を布告しています。髷を結わず散髪してよい、士族でも帯刀しなくてもよいという『勝手令』...
- 明治5年頃の日本人男性の髪型は、ザンギリ頭とちょん髷(まげ)のどちらが多かったか。 | レファレンス協同データベース
明治4年(1871)8月、政府は『散髪脱刀令』を布告して断髪を許し、これを奨励しました。
the Ayutthaya Kingdom, now in southern Thailand,
Ayutthaya was not in southern Thailand. Ayutthaya is in central Thailand; the southern location fits Nakhon Si Thammarat, not Ayutthaya.
Full reasoning
This phrase mislocates Ayutthaya.
UNESCO's page for the Historic City of Ayutthaya states that the site is in Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya Province, and Thailand's National Statistical Office classifies Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya under the central region. By contrast, the same statistical office classifies Nakhon Si Thammarat under the south.
So the sentence appears to have attached the southern-Thailand label to the wrong polity/place. Ayutthaya was a kingdom centered in central Thailand, whereas Nakhon Si Thammarat is in southern Thailand.
3 sources
- Historic City of Ayutthaya - UNESCO World Heritage Centre
At present, it is located in Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya District, Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya Province.
- สำนักงานสถิติแห่งชาติ (NSO) | เว็บไซต์สำนักงานสถิติแห่งชาติ
HOME / Area level Official Statistics / central / Phra Nakhon Si Ayutthaya
- สำนักงานสถิติแห่งชาติ (NSO) | เว็บไซต์สำนักงานสถิติแห่งชาติ
HOME / Area level Official Statistics / south / Nakhon Si Thammarat
In 1853, the United States forced Japan to open its borders to foreign trade, dragging the insular country into the industrial age.
1853 is too early, and 'foreign trade' overstates what happened then. Perry arrived in 1853, but the 1854 Treaty of Kanagawa did not open Japan to trade; the commercial opening came with the 1858 Harris Treaty.
Full reasoning
This compresses several distinct events into one inaccurate statement.
According to the U.S. Department of State's Office of the Historian, Perry sailed into Edo Bay on July 8, 1853 and delivered President Fillmore's letter announcing that the United States sought to open relations with Japan. But the same source says formal recognition came in 1854, and full diplomatic relations were established in 1858 with the Treaty of Amity and Commerce.
The U.S. National Archives is even more explicit about the 1854 treaty's limits: the Treaty of Kanagawa protected American whalers and provided coaling ports, but "He did not, however, open Japan to trade. It wasn't until 1858" that a commercial treaty was achieved.
So the claim is wrong on both date and substance: Perry's 1853 arrival did not itself open Japan's borders to foreign trade, and the first agreement in 1854 was not yet a full trade opening.
2 sources
- Japan - Countries - Office of the Historian
On July 8, 1853, Commodore Perry had sailed into the harbor of Japan's capital of Edo (now Tokyo) and delivered a letter... Formal recognition... had to wait until the treaty of 1854... Full diplomatic relations were established on July 29, 1858 with the signing of a Treaty of Amity and Commerce.
- The Treaty of Kanagawa | National Archives
He did not, however, open Japan to trade. It wasn't until 1858 that the U.S. Consul at last achieved Perry's final objective: establishing a commercial treaty.