x.com/38divan/status/2101187491927621995?s=46
2 corrections found
King Salman celebrated him as the victorious leader who defeated Iraq, gave him gifts, and gave him (the Ka'ba Kiswah)
Bush’s 2008 Saudi visit was hosted by King Abdullah, not King Salman, and contemporaneous records describe gifts such as a sword, dagger, robe, and traditional clothing—not the Kaaba’s kiswah.
Full reasoning
Official U.S. and Saudi records do not match this description.
- The U.S. State Department’s presidential travel history lists George W. Bush’s January 14–16, 2008 trip to Saudi Arabia as a visit where he “Met with King Abdullah.”
- A White House archival photo from that visit identifies Salman as “Prince Salman bin Abdul Al-Aziz” during Bush’s stop in Riyadh, not as king.
- A contemporaneous Saudi report about the same visit says Prince Salman gave Bush a commemorative gift consisting of a sword, a dagger, a farwa/overcoat, and traditional clothing.
- The U.S. Federal Register’s 2008 foreign-gifts report likewise records Bush receiving items from Saudi officials such as a robe/overcoat, dagger, sabre, medal, and book. It does not record a Kaaba kiswah as a gift from Salman.
So the post conflates the identities of the Saudi hosts and misstates the gift: Bush’s visit was with King Abdullah, while Prince Salman appeared in Riyadh ceremonies, and the documented gifts were traditional garments and weapons, not the Kaaba’s kiswah.
4 sources
- Saudi Arabia - Travels of the President - Travels - Department History - Office of the Historian
George W. Bush — Riyadh, Al-Janadriyah — Met with King Abdullah. January 14-16, 2008.
- President George W. Bush and Prince Salman bin Abdul Al-Aziz, right, join sword dancers Tuesday, Jan. 15, 2008, during the President's visit to Al Murabba Palace in Riyadh.
President George W. Bush and Prince Salman bin Abdul Al-Aziz, right, join sword dancers Tuesday, Jan. 15, 2008, during the President's visit to Al Murabba Palace in Riyadh.
- بوش يُشارك في العرضة والأمير سلمان يهديه سيفا وملابس تراثية
وفي ختام الزيارة قدم سمو الامير سلمان بن عبدالعزيز لفخامته هدية تذكارية بهذه المناسبة تضمنت سيفا وخنجرا وفروة وملابس تراثية تقليدية...
- Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 121 / Thursday, June 25, 2009 / Notices
For Jan. 15, 2008, the Federal Register lists Saudi gifts to the President including a traditional brown farwa (over-coat), silver and gold dagger, silver and gold sabre, book, navy suede robe, and King Abd al-Aziz Medal of Honor gold necklace; it does not list a Kaaba kiswah.
went to Saudi Arabia's Najd and Hijaz regions.
Official itineraries for Bush’s 2008 Saudi trips list Riyadh and Al-Janadriyah only; they do not show a visit to the Hijaz.
Full reasoning
The available official travel records for George W. Bush’s 2008 visits to Saudi Arabia do not show him visiting the Hijaz.
- The U.S. State Department’s presidential travel history lists Bush’s Saudi destinations in both January and May 2008 as “Riyadh, Al-Janadriyah.”
- Al-Janadriyah is a site on the outskirts of Riyadh, according to the Saudi Press Agency.
- Those locations are in/around Riyadh, not the Hijaz cities such as Jeddah, Mecca, or Medina.
So the claim that Bush went to both the Najd and Hijaz regions is not supported by the official itinerary; the documented stops were in the Riyadh/Al-Janadriyah area.
2 sources
- Saudi Arabia - Travels of the President - Travels - Department History - Office of the Historian
George W. Bush — Riyadh, Al-Janadriyah — Met with King Abdullah. January 14-16, 2008. George W. Bush — Riyadh, Al-Janadriyah — Met with King Abdullah. May 16-17, 2008.
- Diplomatic corps heads and families visit Janadriyah
Al-Janadriyah village, outskirts of Riyadh city...