en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fourth_Estate_(painting)
3 corrections found
La Fiumana by Giuseppe Pellizza da Volpedo, 1898, oil on canvas, 255 x 438 cm. Palazzo Citterio, Milan.
The year in this caption is wrong. Official museum and cultural-heritage records date Fiumana to 1895–1896, not 1898.
Full reasoning
This caption gives 1898 as the date for Fiumana, but authoritative catalog records do not. Palazzo Citterio’s official collection page lists the painting’s year as 1895–1896 and says the canvas "was painted by Pellizza da Volpedo between 1895 and 1896." Italy’s General Catalog of Cultural Heritage likewise catalogs Fiumana as a painting from 1895–1896 and notes that Pellizza returned to the subject only later, in 1898, when he began painting Il Quarto Stato. So the caption appears to have shifted the start of Il Quarto Stato onto Fiumana by mistake.
2 sources
- Fiumana | Palazzo Citterio
Technical Details ... Year 1895 - 1896 ... The monumental canvas was painted by Pellizza da Volpedo between 1895 and 1896 and never finished.
- Fiumana corteo dipinto 1895 - 1896
Fiumana. corteo dipinto 1895 - 1896 ... La tela venne poi lasciata incompiuta da Pellizza che nel 1898 ritornò sullo stesso tema iniziando a dipingere il "Quarto Stato".
Giacomo Bidone, later known as Giacomo Maria Clemente Silvestro, born in Volpedo on October 16, 1884. He remained there, working as a carpenter and remaining a widower after the death of his wife Lucotti, until 1891, when he moved to Viguzzolo. From there, he emigrated to America, following the footsteps of his uncle.
These dates do not add up. Official Pellizza materials identify Giacomo Bidone as born in 1844, not 1884, and say he emigrated after 1891.
Full reasoning
This biographical note is internally inconsistent and conflicts with the Pellizza association’s own educational material.
- The article says Giacomo Bidone was born in 1884 but had already remained in Volpedo as a working carpenter, become a widower, and moved away by 1891. That would make him about 7 years old at the time of the move, which is incompatible with the rest of the sentence.
- The official educational PDF published by the Associazione Pellizza da Volpedo instead identifies Giacomo Bidone as a carpenter born in Volpedo on 16 November 1844, and says that after 1891 he emigrated to America.
So the entry’s birth year is almost certainly wrong, and the chronology built on it is impossible as written.
2 sources
- Microsoft Word - 1 I bambini .doc (Associazione Pellizza da Volpedo educational PDF)
Giacomo Bidone falegname nato a Volpedo il 16 novembre 1844. Dopo il 1891 emigra in America.
- Una Spoon River nel Quarto Stato - La Stampa
Ne conosciamo molti: per esempio il falegname Giacomo Bidone (al fianco di Zarri/Gatti), che emigrò in America, senza dar più notizie di sé.
Il Camino dei Lavoratori
The title is misspelled here. The work’s title is *Il cammino dei lavoratori*, with a double 'm'.
Full reasoning
This appears to be a title error rather than a disputed interpretation. The Pellizza association’s own materials repeatedly give the preparatory work’s title as Il cammino dei lavoratori. The same official page lists it as item 8 in the sequence leading to Il Quarto Stato and also quotes Pellizza referring to Il cammino dei lavoratori by that spelling. So Camino here is incorrect; the correct Italian title is Cammino.
1 source
- Il "cantiere" del Quarto Stato - Pellizza da Volpedo
Il Quarto Stato che fu nella mia mente Fiumana prima, quindi Il cammino dei lavoratori ... 8 - Il cammino dei lavoratori (1898), olio su tela, cm 66×116, collezione privata.