en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goblin
3 corrections found
appearing around 1140 in Orderic Vitalis's Historia ecclesiastica, referring to a demon expelled from a church in Évreux.
Orderic Vitalis’s story is about a demon driven from the temple of Diana at Évreux, not from a church.
Full reasoning
The article misstates the setting of Orderic Vitalis’s account.
A Norman-language reference work summarizing the passage quotes Orderic’s Latin: “Dæmon enim, quem de Dianæ fano expulit [Taurinus]...” and translates it as the demon Saint Taurin drove out of the temple of Diana at Évreux. That directly contradicts the article’s claim that the demon was expelled from a church.
A second source paraphrasing Orderic says the same thing in English: Saint Taurin “expelled from the temple of Diana a horrible demon” whom the common people called Gobelin. So the location in the article is wrong: it should refer to a pagan temple (the temple of Diana), not a church.
2 sources
- Goubelin - Wikimanche
« Dæmon enim, quem de Dianæ fano expulit [Taurinus]... Hunc vulgus gobelinum appellat » ... translated as Saint Taurin having driven the demon out of the temple of Diana at Évreux.
- Through Normandy
According to Orderic, St. Taurin ... expelled from the temple of Diana a horrible demon ... The vulgar call him Gobelin.
In The Lord of the Rings, the same creatures are primarily referred to as orcs where the goblin name was used for the lesser orcs.
Tolkien did not use “goblin” for lesser orcs. He used “goblin” as a general translation of “orc,” and “hobgoblin” for larger kinds.
Full reasoning
This sentence misstates Tolkien’s terminology.
In the author’s note to The Hobbit, Tolkien explicitly says that “Orc is not an English word” and that it is “usually translated goblin (or hobgoblin for the larger kinds)”. That means goblin was not a special label for lesser orcs; it was the usual English translation of orc.
Tolkien later reinforced the same point in his Guide to the Names in The Lord of the Rings, writing that “It was translated ‘goblin’ in The Hobbit, except in one place”. Again, that treats goblin as a translation term for the race generally, not as a subclass meaning “lesser orcs.”
So the article’s distinction is backwards: Tolkien’s own note says hobgoblin was used for the larger kinds, not goblin for the lesser ones.
2 sources
- The Hobbit
“Orc is not an English word. It occurs in one or two places but is usually translated goblin (or hobgoblin for the larger kinds).”
- Guide to the Names in The Lord of the Rings
“It was translated ‘goblin’ in The Hobbit, except in one place; but this word ... [is] not really suitable.”
Spider-Man 3 (2007) and The Amazing Spider-Man 2 (2014) as Harry Osborn
This overstates Spider-Man 3: Harry Osborn is presented there as the New Goblin, not the Green Goblin.
Full reasoning
This sentence groups two Harry Osborn film appearances together as Green Goblin appearances, but that is not accurate for Spider-Man 3.
Sony’s official page for Spider-Man 3 identifies James Franco’s villain as “the New Goblin”, listing the film’s villains as Sandman, Venom, and the New Goblin (James Franco). IMDb’s cast listing for the movie likewise credits James Franco as “New Goblin / Harry Osborn.”
So while Harry Osborn is a goblin-themed villain in Spider-Man 3, the film does not present him as the Green Goblin there. The article’s wording incorrectly folds Spider-Man 3 into Green Goblin appearances by Harry Osborn.
2 sources
- Spider-Man 3 (2007) - Full cast & crew - IMDb
The cast listing identifies James Franco as “New Goblin / Harry Osborn.”
- SPIDER-MAN™ 3 | Sony Pictures Entertainment
Sony’s official synopsis says Spider-Man faces Sandman, Venom, and “the New Goblin (James Franco).”