All corrections
LessWrong April 2, 2026 at 11:52 PM

www.lesswrong.com/posts/xezLdonsRbdDj2CAx/how-social-ideas-get-corrupt

1 correction found

1
Claim
The author, Marshall Rosenberg, literally starts the chapter on how to communicate empathetically by implying that anyone who doesn’t follow these principles is “behaving violently” and being “life-alienating”.
Correction

This misidentifies where the quoted passage appears in Rosenberg’s book. The passage begins Chapter 2, “Communication That Blocks Compassion,” not the chapter “Receiving Empathically” or a chapter on how to communicate empathetically.

Full reasoning

The article quotes Rosenberg’s lines about “life-alienating communication” and says he “starts the chapter on how to communicate empathetically” that way. But the book’s table of contents shows “Receiving empathically” is a later chapter, while the quoted lines appear under the heading “Communication That Blocks Compassion.”

Open Library’s catalog record for Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life lists the table of contents in order: “Giving from the heart,” “Communication that blocks compassion,”“Receiving empathically.” That means “Receiving empathically” is not the chapter opened by the quoted passage.

A searchable PDF of the 3rd edition places the quoted text directly under the Chapter 2 heading “Communication That Blocks Compassion.” The relevant lines read that Rosenberg had identified forms of language that “contribute to our behaving violently” and that he uses the term “life-alienating communication” for them, immediately beneath that chapter title.

So the problem is not whether the quoted words exist—they do—but that the post incorrectly says they start the chapter on communicating empathetically.

2 sources
  • Open Library — Nonviolent communication: a language of life

    Table of Contents: Giving from the heart : the heart of nonviolent communication; Communication that blocks compassion; ... Receiving empathically; The power of empathy...

  • Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life (searchable PDF)

    Chapter heading: “Communication That Blocks Compassion.” Immediately below it: “I have identified specific forms of language and communication that I believe contribute to our behaving violently toward each other and ourselves. I use the term life-alienating communication to refer to these forms of communication.”

Model: OPENAI_GPT_5 Prompt: v1.16.0