en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maria_Yudina
1 correction found
After an incident during one of her recitals in Leningrad, when she read Boris Pasternak's poetry from the stage as an encore, Yudina was banned from performing for five years. In 1966, when the ban was lifted, she gave a cycle of lectures on Romanticism at the Moscow Conservatory.
This conflates two separate episodes. The 1961 Leningrad encore got Yudina barred from the Leningrad Philharmonia, while her broader all-concert ban was imposed later, in 1963, and lasted about three years rather than five.
Full reasoning
Recent scholarship and an official Moscow Conservatory biography do not support a five-year general performance ban beginning with the 1961 Leningrad recital.
What the evidence shows instead:
-
The Leningrad encore led to a ban from the Leningrad Philharmonia, not a five-year all-performance ban. In a 2024 Cambridge University Press article, Adam Behan quotes Yudina's own retrospective account of the 19 November 1961 recital where she read Zabolotsky and Pasternak, then states: "what is certain is that Yudina’s performance earned her a permanent ban from the Leningrad Philharmonia — she did not perform in concert there again." The same article adds that she subsequently performed elsewhere in Leningrad, which contradicts the idea that this incident triggered a blanket ban on performing everywhere.
-
Her wider public-concert ban came later, in 1963, after the Khabarovsk denunciation. The same Cambridge article explains that after the 1963 Khabarovsk affair, official Alexander Kholodilin "handed her an indefinite ban on all public concert performances" and that "In the end, the ban lasted for three years", with the article noting that it was lifted in late 1966.
-
The Moscow Conservatory's own biography also places the loss of her ability to concertize in 1963, not after the 1961 Leningrad recital. Its entry on Yudina says: "В 1960 году была уволена из ГМПИ им. Гнесиных, в 1963 - лишена возможности концертировать" ("In 1960 she was dismissed from the Gnessin Institute; in 1963 she was deprived of the possibility of giving concerts"). The same page separately notes her 1966 lecture cycle on Romanticism.
So the article's sentence is misleading because it merges:
- the 1961 Leningrad Philharmonia exclusion, and
- the 1963–late 1966 broader concert ban.
That makes the stated cause, scope, and duration of the ban inaccurate.
2 sources
- Music History, the Practice Turn, and Maria Yudina’s Journey through the Soviet ‘Thaw’, 1959–63
The article states that the 19 November 1961 performance 'earned her a permanent ban from the Leningrad Philharmonia' and notes that 'Yudina did, however, subsequently perform elsewhere in Leningrad.' It later says Kholodilin imposed 'an indefinite ban on all public concert performances' in 1963 and that 'In the end, the ban lasted for three years.'
- Московская консерватория - персоналии - Юдина Мария Вениаминовна
The official biography says: 'В 1960 году была уволена из ГМПИ им. Гнесиных, в 1963 - лишена возможности концертировать' and separately notes the 1966 lecture cycle 'Романтизм - истоки и параллели'.