en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pope_Paul_V
4 corrections found
papal Accademia dei Lincei
The Accademia dei Lincei was not a papal academy in 1611. It was a private academy founded by Federico Cesi in 1603 and only became a pontifical academy in 1847.
Full reasoning
The wording is anachronistic. The Accademia dei Lincei’s own history says Federico Cesi founded it in Rome in 1603 with three young colleagues, and that Galileo was among its members from 1611. The same official history says it was only later, in 1847, that Pius IX re-established it as the "Pontificia Accademia dei Nuovi Lincei". So describing the 1611 academy as "papal" is incorrect.
1 source
- Storia | Accademia dei Lincei
Federico Cesi ... fondò a Roma nel 1603 ... l'Accademia dei Lincei ... contò dal 1611 tra i suoi Soci il gran nome di Galileo ... Pio IX ... nel 1847 ristabilì ... come 'Pontificia Accademia dei Nuovi Lincei'.
canonized Cardinal Albert de Louvain on 9 August 1621.
This date is wrong. Albert of Louvain is listed as canonized on 9 August 1613, and Paul V had died on 28 January 1621, months before 9 August 1621.
Full reasoning
This cannot be correct as written. A Catholic-Hierarchy entry for St. Albert Cardinal de Louvain lists his canonization date as 9 Aug 1613. Separately, the Holy See’s list of popes shows that Paul V’s pontificate ended on 28 Jan 1621. Since Paul V was already dead by January 1621, he could not have canonized Albert on 9 August 1621.
2 sources
- St. Albert Cardinal de Louvain [Catholic-Hierarchy]
St. Albert Cardinal de Louvain ... 9 Aug 1613 Canonized.
- The Holy See
Paul V 16,29.V.1605 28.I.1621
use the geocentric model as a theoretical device.
This gets the model backwards. Bellarmine’s 1616 certificate dealt with Copernicanism/heliocentrism; historians summarize it as permitting Copernican ideas only as a hypothesis, not geocentrism as a theoretical device.
Full reasoning
The surviving 1616 certificate does not say Galileo could use the geocentric model as a theoretical device. Bellarmine’s certificate says Galileo had been notified that the doctrine attributed to Copernicus—that the earth moves around the sun and the sun stands at the center—"cannot be defended or held." A scholarly summary by Maurice Finocchiaro explains Bellarmine’s clarification this way: Galileo was warned not to believe, support, or defend Copernicanism as true, but only as a hypothesis. So if one speaks of a model being usable hypothetically, it is the Copernican/heliocentric model, not the geocentric one.
2 sources
- Galileo Trial || 1616 Documents
Cardinal Bellarmine's Certificate ... the doctrine attributed to Copernicus (that the earth moves around the sun and the sun stands at the center of the world ...) is contrary to Holy Scripture and therefore cannot be defended or held.
- Galileo's First Confrontation with the Inquisition (1616): Four Orders and Three Issues
Bellarmine wrote a certificate clarifying that Galileo had been warned not to believe, support, or defend Copernicanism as true or scripturally compatible, but only as an hypothesis.
financed the completion of St. Peter's Basilica
Paul V funded major work on St. Peter’s, especially the facade, but the basilica itself was not completed until 1626, after his death.
Full reasoning
This overstates Paul V’s role. Official St. Peter’s Basilica materials say construction of the current basilica began in 1506 and was completed in 1626. Paul V died in 1621. A Vatican page on the facade explains that Carlo Maderno worked on the facade from 1607 to 1614 on commission from Paul V, which matches the inscription mentioned in the article. So Paul V did sponsor major phases of the project, but he did not finance the final completion of the entire basilica as such.
2 sources
- St. Peter's Basilica FAQ | St. Peter's Basilica
Construction of the current Saint Peter's Basilica began in 1506 and was completed in 1626.
- Facciata Basilica | Vatican
La facciata della Basilica è opera di Carlo Maderno, che vi lavorò dal 1607 al 1614 su commissione di Paolo V (1605-1621).