x.com/420stonerman69/status/2096521254513586488
1 correction found
there were isolated shots of people jumping out of windows on live broadcasts of 9/11
This is incorrect: contemporaneous TV coverage on September 11, 2001 did include live reports and footage of people falling or jumping from the World Trade Center.
Full reasoning
Primary-source broadcast transcripts from September 11, 2001 contradict this claim.
- In CNN's 10:00 ET live coverage that morning, reporter Rose Arce described watching people at the tower windows and said they "appeared to jump" and that viewers could see them "plummeting from that top floor."
- PBS NewsHour's same-day transcript, in its chronological recap of the attacks using live TV material and witness audio, includes: "people jumping out the windows" and "at least 14 people jumping out of windows."
Those are contemporaneous records of live television coverage from the day itself. So the post's implication that memories of live-broadcast shots of people jumping were fabricated or merely conflated is contradicted by the historical broadcast record.
To be precise: these sources show that such imagery/descriptions did appear on live broadcasts. They do not prove what every classroom TV showed, but they are enough to show the specific claim quoted here is false.
2 sources
- CNN.com - Transcripts: America Under Attack, aired September 11, 2001 - 10:00 ET
Rose Arce: "people... appeared to jump from the top floors" and "you saw them plummeting from that top floor."
- The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer; September 11, 2001 - American Archive of Public Broadcasting
Transcript includes: "people jumping out the windows" and "there's people jumping out of windows, they're seeing at least the 14 people jumping out of windows."