www.lesswrong.com/posts/kuXiSi52wvijw3ftR/the-technique-taboo
2 corrections found
A Chinese major teaches you how to talk about Chinese, not how to read it.
This overstates what Chinese majors do. Official Chinese-major curricula at major universities explicitly require substantial Chinese language study, including reading and writing Chinese texts.
Full reasoning
This claim is incorrect as a blanket description of what a Chinese major teaches.
Official university curricula show that Chinese majors are explicitly built around learning to read, write, and use Chinese, not just "talk about Chinese." For example:
- UC Berkeley's Chinese Language and Culture major says the curriculum balances modern and classical language training and includes Intermediate Chinese, Advanced Chinese, and Introduction to Literary Chinese. Berkeley also describes the major as providing training in advanced communication skills and deep study of Chinese literature and culture.
- Stanford's East Asian Studies, China subplan requires students to complete a minimum of 3 years of modern Chinese language courses, at least one classical Chinese course, and CHINA 111: Literature in 20th Century China as the writing-in-the-major course.
Those requirements directly contradict the statement that a Chinese major teaches students only how to "talk about Chinese, not how to read it." Some programs may vary in emphasis, but the categorical claim is false.
2 sources
- Chinese Language and Cultures Major Requirements | East Asian Languages + Culture University of California, Berkeley
The Chinese Language and Culture major provides a comprehensive, humanistic education... Our curriculum balances intensive modern and classical language training... Major Requirements include Intermediate Chinese, Advanced Chinese, and Introduction to Literary Chinese.
- Major Requirements | EALC
For the East Asian Studies, China Subplan, students take a minimum of 3 years of modern Chinese language courses, must take at least one classical Chinese course, and take CHINA 111: Literature in 20th Century China as part of the Writing in the Major requirement.
An art major teaches you how to talk about masterpieces, not how to create one.
This is contradicted by standard studio-art curricula. Official art-major requirements at major universities include studio-based training, drawing, concentration in media like painting or sculpture, and senior creative projects.
Full reasoning
This claim is inaccurate as a general description of an art major.
Official university art-major requirements show that art majors are not limited to discussing art history or "masterpieces"; they also receive substantial hands-on studio training in making art.
Examples:
- Yale's Art major says students develop a "critical and practical understanding" of visual arts through a studio-based curriculum. The major requires Basic Drawing, multiple studio prerequisites, concentration in areas such as painting/printmaking, sculpture, photography, graphic design, or filmmaking, and a two-term senior project.
- UCLA's undergraduate Art program says the B.A. includes courses in Painting & Drawing, Photography, Sculpture, Ceramics, Interdisciplinary Studio, and New Genres. UCLA states that the program's rigorous studio courses provide students with the tools and curriculum to develop skills in those media.
That evidence directly contradicts the categorical claim that an art major teaches students only how to talk about masterpieces and not how to create art.
2 sources
- Art < Yale University
Students in the Art major develop a critical and practical understanding of the visual arts and design through a studio-based curriculum... Visual Thinking and Basic Drawing are mandatory... The senior requirement consists of a two-term senior project.
- Undergraduate Studies: UCLA Department of Art
The undergraduate (B.A.) program includes courses in Ceramics, Interdisciplinary Studio, New Genres, Painting & Drawing, Photography and Sculpture... The rigorous studio courses at the program's core provide students with the tools, facilities, and curriculum to develop skills.