en.wikipedia.org/wiki/King_Lear
2 corrections found
thereby uniting the kingdoms of the island of Britain into one
James’s 1603 accession created a personal union of the crowns, not a single unified kingdom. England and Scotland remained separate kingdoms with separate institutions until the Acts of Union in 1707.
Full reasoning
This clause overstates what happened in 1603. When James VI of Scotland became James I of England after Elizabeth I's death, England and Scotland shared a monarch, but they did not become a single kingdom at that point. Contemporary historians and official UK sources describe 1603 as the Union of the Crowns or a union under one monarch. The two kingdoms remained constitutionally separate, with separate parliaments and institutions, until the Acts of Union of 1707 created the Kingdom of Great Britain.
So the article's wording is inaccurate because it says James's accession "unit[ed] the kingdoms ... into one", which suggests a full political union in 1603. The more accurate description is that it created a personal union, not one kingdom.
2 sources
- Queen Anne - The National Archives
From 1603 with the reign of James I of England and King James VI of Scotland, there existed a union under one monarch but the Act of Union formally united the English and Scottish crowns to create the Kingdom of Britain.
- Act of Union 1707: Key dates - UK Parliament
1603 - Union of the Crowns: The Kingdoms remain separate but are ruled by a single monarch.
a cattle baron played by Spencer Tracy tyrannizes his three sons, and only the youngest, Joe, played by Robert Wagner, remains loyal
Broken Lance does not feature only three sons. Spencer Tracy’s character has four sons total: three older sons from his first marriage and a fourth son, Joe, by his second wife.
Full reasoning
This sentence misstates the family structure in Broken Lance (1954). Matt Devereaux, played by Spencer Tracy, is not the father of only three sons. Reliable plot summaries describe him as having three sons from his first wife plus a fourth son, Joe, from his later marriage to a Comanche woman.
That means Joe is not one of only three sons; he is the fourth son overall (and the loyal youngest son). The article could accurately say that Devereaux tyrannizes his sons, or that he has three older sons who resent Joe, but saying he tyrannizes his three sons is incorrect.
2 sources
- Broken Lance - Turner Classic Movies
Matt Devereaux (Spencer Tracy) is a stern cattle baron with three sons from his first wife and a fourth son from his current marriage to a Comanche woman.
- Broken Lance - Apple TV
Because Matt's greatest love is for his Indian wife, Princess (Katy Jurado) and their son Joe (Robert Wagner), Matt's three sons from a previous marriage deeply resent them.