x.com/theojaffee/status/2067305700636991618
1 correction found
GPT-5.5 values Timnit Gebru(!!!) the highest out of literally anyone
The CAIS dashboard this post is referring to does not rank Timnit Gebru first for GPT-5.5. In the dashboard’s published People ranking, she appears below multiple other people, including Yoshua Bengio and Stuart Russell.
Full reasoning
The post points to CAIS’s AI Values Dashboard. CAIS explains that the dashboard builds a single people-ranking for each model from thousands of head-to-head choices, and that the GPT-5.5 people ranking is published in its static data files.
In CAIS’s published people.json data, Timnit Gebru is not ranked #1. She appears with an Elo of 2531, below at least 12 other people in the same ranking, including Yoshua Bengio (3016), Stuart Russell (3003), Toby Ord (2888), Jan Leike (2864), Chris Olah (2840), Geoffrey Hinton (2715), Dawn Song (2609), Dan Hendrycks (2600), Dario Amodei (2586), Demis Hassabis (2579), Zico Kolter (2558), and Nicholas Carlini (2553).
So the claim that GPT-5.5 values Timnit Gebru “the highest out of literally anyone” is contradicted by the dashboard’s own published ranking data.
2 sources
- CAIS AI Values Dashboard llms.txt
We ask each model to choose between two options at a time, across thousands of head-to-head pairs, and build a single ranking from all of those choices. ... PEOPLE - /data/exchange_rates.json (GPT-5.5 ranking) ... - /data/board_insights/people.json - the "what we found" writeup plus curated head-to-head pairs.
- CAIS AI Values Dashboard people.json
"entities": [ { "name": "Yoshua Bengio", ... "elo": 3016 }, { "name": "Stuart Russell", ... "elo": 3003 }, ... { "name": "Nicholas Carlini", ... "elo": 2553 }, { "name": "Timnit Gebru", ... "elo": 2531 }, ... ]