en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Letters
2 corrections found
The Royal Society created its charters
The Royal Society did not grant or create its own charters. Its founding charters were granted by King Charles II.
Full reasoning
This wording is inaccurate because a royal charter is issued by the Crown, not self-created by the organization receiving it. The Royal Society’s own archival catalogue states that "Three charters were granted to the Royal Society by its Founder and Patron, King Charles II" (dated 1662, 1663, and 1669). The Royal Society’s official history likewise describes the Society as becoming a chartered organisation and notes that its motto was adopted in its First Charter in 1662. So the Society may have developed internal statutes and governance, but it did not create or grant its own charters.
2 sources
- Search Results — Founding charters of the Royal Society
Three charters were granted to the Royal Society by its Founder and Patron, King Charles II. The first is dated 15 July 1662; the second 22 April 1663; and the third 8 April 1669.
- History of the Royal Society | Royal Society
In the mid-17th century, informal gatherings of London- and Oxford-based intellectuals coalesced to form a chartered organisation... The Royal Society's motto 'Nullius in verba' was adopted in its First Charter in 1662.
Currently, the consensus is that Pierre Bayle first translated the term in his journal Nouvelles de la République des Lettres in 1684.
Bayle was not the first to translate the term into a vernacular language. French and Spanish forms of the phrase are attested well before 1684.
Full reasoning
This claim is contradicted by earlier vernacular uses of the phrase.
A Bibliothèque nationale de France / Gallica result on Robert Estienne’s 1543 Latin-French dictionary says it renders “Gallice Reipublicæ” as “la république des lettres”—which is already a French translation more than a century before Bayle’s 1684 journal.
There is also an earlier Spanish vernacular form: the University of Salamanca’s record for Diego de Saavedra Fajardo’s República literaria dates the manuscript to 1612–1648 and states that the first edition was published posthumously in 1655. That means Bayle was not the first person to translate the Latin expression into a modern language, and if the article means French specifically, the 1543 dictionary evidence shows he was not first there either.
Bayle’s 1684 journal was certainly influential in popularizing the phrase, but "first translated" is too strong and is historically incorrect.
2 sources
- BnF Gallica — Les Estienne et les types
... rend les mots Gallice Reipublicæ par la république des lettres.
- República literaria de don Diego Saavedra Faxardo ... (Ms. 2102) | Universidad de Salamanca
Fecha de publicación 1612-1648 ... Se considera que el manuscrito más antiguo es de 1612, pero la primera edición fue publicada póstumamente, en 1655.