en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libelle_(literary_genre)
2 corrections found
The publishers of libelles were known as libellistes.
“Libelliste” means the writer/author of a libelle, not its publisher.
Full reasoning
French reference dictionaries define libelliste as the person who writes libelles, not the publisher.
- The CNRTL/TLFi entry states: "Libelliste, subst. Personne qui écrit des libelles."
- Le Robert likewise defines libelliste as "Auteur de libelles."
So the article’s wording is inaccurate: a libelliste is an author/libeler/pamphleteer, whereas a publisher would be an éditeur, imprimeur, or libraire depending on role.
2 sources
- LIBELLISTE : Définition de LIBELLISTE
« Libelliste, subst. Personne qui écrit des libelles. »
- libelliste - Définitions, synonymes, prononciation, exemples | Dico en ligne Le Robert
Définition de libelliste : « Auteur de libelles. »
Libelles were invariably of a political nature, both defamatory and subversive.
This overstates the genre: libelles were not only political; scholarship also treats literary and personal polemical attacks as libelles.
Full reasoning
The word "invariably" is too strong here. Scholarly work on libelles shows that they were used not only for political attacks, but also in literary quarrels and against writers.
Evidence:
-
Jean-Alexandre Perras’s article on Simon Linguet studies libelles specifically "dans ... sa querelle littéraire avec André Morellet" and says the category of libelle was used in "querelles (judiciaires ou littéraires)". That is direct evidence of libelles in a literary, not purely political, setting.
-
Stéphanie Gehanne Gavoty’s study of Grimm’s Correspondance littéraire identifies several libelles against Jean-Jacques Rousseau and notes that the targets of libelles included not just political figures but also writers. The article explicitly says: "Les nouvelles figures publiques que sont les écrivains s’adjoignent aux figures politiques ..."
Because reliable scholarship documents libelles in literary and personal polemics, the blanket claim that they were invariably political is incorrect.
2 sources
- L'écriture des libelles chez Simon Linguet, du droit au journalisme - Pratiques et formes littéraires
The article studies libelles in Simon Linguet’s writings, "en particulier ... lors de ... sa querelle littéraire avec André Morellet" and says the category of libelle is often used in "querelles (judiciaires ou littéraires)".
- En quête d'une définition : les libelles dans la Correspondance littéraire de Grimm (1765) - Pratiques et formes littéraires
The article identifies "plusieurs libelles" against Rousseau and states: "Les nouvelles figures publiques que sont les écrivains s’adjoignent aux figures politiques ... la cible ... peut aussi être plus symbolique."