All corrections
Substack July 6, 2026 at 02:34 PM

www.chinatalk.media/p/taiwans-war-on-renewables

4 corrections found

1
Claim
All four nuclear power plants, including the fourth one that never became operational, plus the Lanyu storage site for low-level nuclear waste, went through their siting and construction processes during the martial law era.
Correction

This overstates the timeline for Taiwan’s fourth nuclear plant. Martial law ended in 1987, but official sources say Lungmen (Plant 4) received its construction permit in 1999.

Full reasoning

This sentence is incorrect because it says all four nuclear plants went through their construction processes during the martial law era. Taiwan’s martial law era ended on July 15, 1987. But the Nuclear Safety Commission says it issued the construction permit for the fourth nuclear power project (Lungmen) in 1999, well after martial law had ended. So even if some planning for Lungmen predated democratization, its construction process did not take place entirely during martial law.

That means the statement is too broad: it may fit the first three plants better than the fourth, but it is not accurate as written for all four plants.

2 sources
2
Claim
renewable generation is the only thing Taipower doesn’t own.
Correction

Taipower does own renewable generation. Its own smart-grid page lists company-installed solar, wind, geothermal, and hydro capacity.

Full reasoning

This claim is contradicted by Taipower’s own published data. On its official Smart Grid "Green Energy" page, Taipower says that part of Taiwan’s installed solar, wind, geothermal, and hydro capacity was "installed by our company." The same page names Taipower-operated renewable assets such as Tainan Salt Field PV, Zhangbin Field PV, Changgong Wind Farm, Changung Offshore Wind Farm, Renze Geothermal Field, and Lanyang hydro power.

So it is inaccurate to say renewable generation is the only thing Taipower does not own. Taipower clearly owns and operates multiple renewable-energy assets.

1 source
  • GreenEnergy - Taipower Smart Grid

    By February 2026, the cumulative grid connected solar photovoltaic capacity is total 15.06 GW... 0.38 GW of them were installed by our company... wind turbine capacity is total 4.626 GW... 0.442 GW of them were installed by our company... geothermal capacity is 9.48 MW, 0.84 MW of them were installed by our company... hydro power... 1.826 GW of Conventional Hydro and 2.602 GW of Pumped Storage Hydropower were installed by our company.

3
Claim
All of the electricity Taipower generates comes from LNG, coal, and nuclear
Correction

Taipower also generates renewable electricity. Its own official materials list Taipower-installed solar, wind, geothermal, and hydro capacity.

Full reasoning

This is false on its face because Taipower’s official materials show that the company generates electricity from renewable sources too, not just LNG, coal, and nuclear.

Taipower’s Smart Grid "Green Energy" page says the company itself has installed 0.38 GW of solar, 0.442 GW of wind, 0.84 MW of geothermal, and large amounts of hydro capacity. Those are generation assets owned by Taipower and producing electricity. Since Taipower operates renewable generation, it is incorrect to say all of the electricity it generates comes only from LNG, coal, and nuclear.

1 source
  • GreenEnergy - Taipower Smart Grid

    By February 2026... 0.38 GW of [solar] were installed by our company... 0.442 GW of [wind] were installed by our company... 0.84 MW of [geothermal] were installed by our company... 1.826 GW of Conventional Hydro and 2.602 GW of Pumped Storage Hydropower were installed by our company.

4
Claim
100% of transmission, distribution, and retail.
Correction

Taipower still dominates transmission and distribution, but retail is not 100% Taipower. Taiwan’s Energy Administration lists many licensed renewable electricity retailers besides Taipower.

Full reasoning

This is inaccurate because Taiwan does not have 100% Taipower control of electricity retail.

The Energy Administration’s official list of renewable electricity retailers includes many non-Taipower companies alongside Taipower itself. That means retail has been at least partially opened: Taipower remains the public utility and still dominates the system, but retail is not literally 100% Taipower.

So the statement overstates Taipower’s monopoly by treating retail as fully exclusive when the government’s own records show numerous other licensed electricity retailers are operating.

2 sources
Model: OPENAI_GPT_5 Prompt: v1.16.0