www.lesswrong.com/posts/A2kJKqnHhh5Hq4p2S/we-must-remember-that-our-world-contai...
3 corrections found
In 2007, 3.2% of US chickens were cage-free, but now, as a result of corporate campaigns, only 45% are.
This overstates what the USDA number refers to. The cage-free percentage is for the U.S. egg-laying flock, not for all U.S. chickens.
Full reasoning
USDA sources describe cage-free shares as a measure of egg-laying hens / the table egg-laying flock, not all chickens in the United States.
- USDA ERS says: "Cage-free hens ... comprise a growing percentage of the U.S. egg-laying flock."
- USDA NASS separately reports that the U.S. produced 9.40 billion broilers in 2025, showing that "all U.S. chickens" is a much broader category than the laying flock used in cage-free reports.
So the sentence is inaccurate as written: it generalizes a statistic about laying hens to US chickens overall.
2 sources
- Growing share of egg-laying hens are cage-free | Economic Research Service
Cage-free hens, which unlike caged hens are free to roam during the laying cycle, comprise a growing percentage of the U.S. egg-laying flock.
- Poultry - Production and Value 2025 Summary | USDA National Agricultural Statistics Service
The total number of broilers produced in 2025 was 9.40 billion, up 1 percent from 2024.
from 2006 to 2023, governments had completely eliminated the screw worm from North America.
This gets the history wrong. USDA says New World screwworm was eradicated from the United States in 1966, while 2006 refers to the Panama barrier zone—and there was also a Florida outbreak in 2016–2017.
Full reasoning
USDA APHIS gives a different timeline than the post.
- APHIS says the United States and Panama have maintained a barrier zone in eastern Panama since 2006 to keep New World screwworm from moving north.
- Separately, APHIS says New World screwworm was eradicated from the United States in 1966.
- APHIS also says there was a small outbreak in the Florida Keys in 2017 after the 2016 introduction, which means it was not simply "completely eliminated from North America from 2006 to 2023" without interruption.
So 2006 is not the date North America was first "completely eliminated" of screwworm; it is the date of the Panama barrier-zone arrangement, and the Florida 2016–2017 outbreak also breaks the claim's timeline.
2 sources
- New World screwworm & equines updates January 17, 2025 | APHIS
Since 2006, the United States and Panama have maintained a barrier zone in eastern Panama intended to prevent NWS from moving north from South America to screwworm-free areas in Central and North America.
- New World Screwworm Prevention for Animals | APHIS
Using sterile insect technique, we eradicated NWS from the United States in 1966 and successfully eliminated a small outbreak from the Florida Keys in 2017.
The main problem is that they’re simply illegal because they often make use of psychedelic substances.
This is misleading because standard cluster-headache treatments are legal. Clinical guidance recommends legal treatments such as oxygen, triptans, and verapamil.
Full reasoning
Major clinical guidance does not describe cluster headache treatment as "simply illegal" or mainly dependent on psychedelics.
- NICE recommends oxygen and subcutaneous or nasal triptans for acute cluster headache, and verapamil for prevention.
- The NHS likewise says the main treatments include triptans and oxygen, and preventive medicines can include corticosteroids, verapamil or lithium.
Psychedelics have been studied for cluster headache, but the standard recommended treatments are legal, established medicines. So the sentence is inaccurate as a description of what the main treatment problem is.
2 sources
- Recommendations | Headaches in over 12s: diagnosis and management | NICE
Offer oxygen and/or a subcutaneous or nasal triptan for the acute treatment of cluster headache... Consider verapamil for prophylactic treatment during a bout of cluster headache.
- Cluster headaches - NHS
If a cluster headache has already started, the main treatments include: medicines called triptans... oxygen... Treatments to prevent a cluster headache... can include corticosteroids, verapamil or lithium.