en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urdu
4 corrections found
Shah Abdul Qadir Raipuri was the first person who translated The Quran into Urdu.
This confuses two different people. The earliest complete Urdu Qur’an translation is credited to Shah Abdul Qadir Dehlavi, not the 20th-century scholar Abdul Qadir Raipuri.
Full reasoning
This sentence appears to mix up Shah Abdul Qadir Dehlavi with Shah Abdul Qadir Raipuri.
Credible sources on Urdu Qur’an translation identify the earliest complete and published Urdu translation as the work of Shah Abdul Qadir of Delhi (also called Dehlavi/Dehlawi), not Abdul Qadir Raipuri. Dawn, summarizing Urdu scholar Jamil Jalibi, states that Shah Abdul Qadir’s translation, published from Delhi in 1829, is the first complete and published Urdu translation of the Quran.
By contrast, academic sources identify Abd al-Qadir Raipuri as a much later figure: a Deobandi religious scholar who lived 1878–1962. That makes it impossible for him to have been the first Urdu translator of the Qur’an, which predates him by decades.
So the claim is incorrect because it attributes the milestone to the wrong Abdul Qadir.
2 sources
- LITERARY NOTES: A linguistic perspective on Urdu translations of Quran - DAWN.COM
According to Dr Jameel Jalibi, Shah Abdul Qadir’s translation, published from Delhi in 1829, is the first, complete and published Urdu translation of the Quran.
- University of Chicago dissertation discussing Abd al-Qadir Raipuri
... ʿAbd al-Qādir Raīpūrī (1878-1962) ... one of the key successors of Rashid Gangohi.
There are over 100 million native speakers of Urdu in India and Pakistan together
The article’s own country figures do not add up to 100 million native speakers. Official census figures put Urdu mother-tongue speakers at about 50.8 million in India and 22.25 million in Pakistan, or roughly 73 million combined.
Full reasoning
This sentence overstates the combined number of native Urdu speakers in India and Pakistan.
Official Indian census data lists 50,772,631 Urdu mother-tongue speakers in India in 2011. Pakistan Bureau of Statistics lists 22,249,307 Urdu mother-tongue speakers in Pakistan in the 2023 census. Added together, that is about 73.0 million, not “over 100 million.”
So while Urdu has far more than 100 million speakers if second-language speakers are included, the claim specifically says native speakers, and that is contradicted by the official counts cited in the same paragraph.
2 sources
- Census of India 2011, Table C-16: Population by mother tongue
22 URDU ... 5,07,72,631
- Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, Table 11: Population by Mother Tongue, Census-2023
URDU ... PAKISTAN ... ALL SEXES 240,458,089 22,249,307 ...
5.08 million Urdu speakers
This number is off by a factor of ten. The 2011 Census of India recorded about 50.8 million Urdu mother-tongue speakers, not 5.08 million.
Full reasoning
The figure given here appears to have lost a zero.
The official 2011 Census of India reports 5,07,72,631 Urdu mother-tongue speakers nationwide, i.e. about 50.8 million. That means the article’s phrase “5.08 million Urdu speakers” understates the count by roughly 45 million people.
The surrounding claim that Urdu speakers declined between 2001 and 2011 may refer to a modest decrease from the 2001 total, but the specific number printed here is plainly incorrect.
2 sources
- Census of India 2011, Table C-16: Population by mother tongue
22 URDU ... 5,07,72,631
- Census of India linguistic survey material for Bihar (Urdu section)
According to 2011 census Urdu is spoken by 5,07,72,631 speakers in India.
West Bengal (additional)
This overstates Urdu’s status in West Bengal. Under West Bengal law, Urdu is used officially only in districts, subdivisions, blocks, or municipalities where Urdu speakers exceed 10% of the population.
Full reasoning
The infobox wording implies that Urdu has additional-official-language status across all of West Bengal. But the governing state law is narrower.
The West Bengal Official Language (Amendment) Act, 2012 says Urdu is to be used officially only in local areas “where the population of Urdu speaking people exceeds ten per cent”—specifically, in a district, subdivision, block, or municipality meeting that threshold. That is not the same as statewide additional-official status.
So describing West Bengal simply as “West Bengal (additional)” is misleading without the legal limitation to qualifying local areas.
2 sources
- The West Bengal Official Language (Amendment) Act, 2012
where the population of Urdu speaking people exceeds ten per cent ... the Bengali language and the Urdu language ... may be used ... in the Districts or Sub-division or Block or Municipality
- PRS annual review noting West Bengal official-language framework
West Bengal passed the West Bengal Official Language (Amendment) Bill, 2021 to include Telugu in the list of recognised official languages in the state.