en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Empty_nose_syndrome
2 corrections found
Kern and Eric Moore published a case study of 242 people with secondary atrophic rhinitis in 2001
Moore and Kern’s 2001 paper was a review of 242 atrophic-rhinitis cases, not a case study of 242 secondary atrophic-rhinitis patients. The paper explicitly included both primary and secondary atrophic rhinitis.
Full reasoning
The cited 2001 paper is titled "Atrophic rhinitis: a review of 242 cases", not a case study of 242 secondary-atrophic-rhinitis patients. Its abstract states that the cohort consisted of patients with atrophic rhinitis generally, and that patients were then classified as primary if the condition developed in a previously healthy nose and secondary if it developed after sinonasal surgery, trauma, or chronic granulomatous disease. That directly contradicts the Wikipedia sentence, which says the paper was a case study of 242 people with secondary atrophic rhinitis.
So there are two concrete errors in the quoted sentence:
- it misstates the paper type (review of cases vs. “case study”), and
- it misstates the study population (242 atrophic-rhinitis cases overall, not 242 secondary cases).
2 sources
- Atrophic rhinitis: a review of 242 cases - PubMed
Atrophic rhinitis: a review of 242 cases ... Patients were diagnosed with primary atrophic rhinitis if their condition developed in a previously healthy nose and secondary atrophic rhinitis if their condition developed after sinonasal surgery, trauma, or chronic granulomatous disease.
- Atrophic Rhinitis: A Review of 242 Cases
Atrophic Rhinitis: A Review of 242 Cases ... Patients were diagnosed with primary atrophic rhinitis if their condition developed in a previously healthy nose and secondary atrophic rhinitis if their condition developed after sinonasal surgery, trauma, or chronic granulomatous disease.
Nose 2000, a meeting of the International Rhinologic Society that occurs every four years
The International Rhinologic Society did not meet on a fixed four-year cycle. Official society materials show a next IRS meeting in 2003, just three years after Nose 2000, and later meetings in 2019, 2022, and 2024.
Full reasoning
This clause incorrectly describes the International Rhinologic Society meeting schedule as a once-every-four-years event. Official American Rhinologic Society coverage of Nose 2000 states that the next meeting of the International Rhinologic Society would be held in 2003, which is only three years later. The current official IRS meetings page also lists events in 2019, 2022, and 2024, which again are not separated by four-year intervals.
So the problem is not that Nose 2000 did not happen; it did. The error is the claim that the meeting "occurs every four years." Official society materials contradict that schedule.
2 sources
- American Rhinologic Society Newsletter (Nose News 2000)
Approximately 1400 Rhinologists from over 70 countries came to Washington... The next meeting of the International Rhinologic Society will be held in 2003 in Korea with Professor In-Yong Park as President.
- Meetings - International Rhinologic Society
The official IRS meetings page lists events in 2019 (Rhinoworld Chicago), 2022 (Saint Petersburg Rhinology World Congress / 22nd Congress of the IRS), and 2024 (Heart for Rhinology IRS 2024), showing the society does not meet on a fixed four-year interval.