www.noahpinion.blog/p/europes-crusade-against-air-conditioning?utm_source=substa...
1 correction found
in Geneva you have to show a medical need for it.
Geneva does not generally require a medical reason to approve air conditioning. Its official rules allow permits when cooling need is demonstrated by overheating or internal-load criteria; medical need is only one special derogation route.
Full reasoning
The Canton of Geneva’s official guidance does not say that an applicant must generally prove a medical need to install comfort air conditioning.
Instead, the standard approval path is to show that cooling is needed because the building cannot maintain minimum summer comfort even after architectural/technical measures are used. Geneva says AC installations "may be authorised" if "the proof of the need to cool is demonstrated", including cases where the room temperature exceeds the SIA 180 comfort threshold for a specified number of hours, or where internal heat loads exceed specified limits.
The same page then lists medical necessity separately, under "Dérogation" (derogation/exemption): a request for derogation is possible if "the installation is necessary for medical reasons". In other words, a medical certificate is one special-case exception, not the general rule for all AC permits.
So the article’s wording is too strong: Geneva requires an energy/building permit and proof of cooling need under technical criteria, not a blanket showing of medical need.
2 sources
- Installation de climatisation de confort | ge.ch
Elles peuvent être autorisées aux conditions principales suivantes: ... la preuve du besoin de climatiser est démontrée ... la température du local dépasse la température maximale de confort ... ou les charges internes dépassent ...
- Installation de climatisation de confort | ge.ch
Dérogation ... Une demande de dérogation ... est possible dans les cas suivants: l'installation est nécessaire pour des raisons médicales ... Lorsque l'installation est nécessaire pour des raisons médicales ... Un certificat médical est à joindre.