en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miscibility
3 corrections found
Immiscible metals are unable to form alloys with each other.
This is incorrect because immiscible metals can still form alloys; they usually form multiphase or phase-separated alloys rather than a single homogeneous solid solution.
Full reasoning
In materials science, an alloy is a metallic material made from two or more elements; it does not have to be a single-phase, fully miscible solid solution. U.S. Department of Energy material explains that “metal alloys are materials that contain two or more atomic metal elements.” A separate OSTI-hosted research paper explicitly discusses “immiscible metal alloy systems” and “Cu-Ta immiscible alloy thin films,” showing that metals can be immiscible and still form alloys. The usual consequence of immiscibility is phase separation or a heterogeneous microstructure, not the impossibility of alloy formation.
2 sources
- In Some Metals, There Is Strength in Order | U.S. DOE Office of Science
Metal alloys are materials that contain two or more atomic metal elements.
- Microstructural characterization of phase-separated co-deposited Cu-Ta immiscible alloy thin films
Immiscible metal alloy systems are subject to phase separating driving forces... Cu-Ta immiscible alloy thin films.
neither is miscible in liquid lead
This is incorrect for silver: silver and lead do form a single liquid alloy phase, and the Parkes process works because silver is more soluble in zinc than in lead, not because silver is immiscible with molten lead.
Full reasoning
This sentence overstates the behavior of silver in molten lead. The NIST Ag–Pb phase-diagram page lists a single liquid phase, shown as L with model (Ag,Pb), which is the standard notation for a liquid solution of silver and lead rather than two immiscible liquids. In other words, molten silver and molten lead are liquid-miscible.
A National Library of Medicine / NCBI reference on lead refining describes the Parkes process differently: precious metals are removed because they are more soluble in zinc than in lead. That only makes sense if silver is already soluble in molten lead bullion. So the clause saying silver is not miscible in liquid lead is incorrect.
2 sources
- Ag-Pb Phase Diagram & Computational Thermodynamics | NIST
Phases... Liquid ... L ... (Ag,Pb)1 ; Calculated Invariant Equilibria: L -> (Ag) + (Pb) at 303.7 oC.
- Inorganic and Organic Lead Compounds | NCBI Bookshelf
The removal of the precious metals by the Parkes process is based on the fact that they are more soluble in zinc than in lead.
the zinc is then boiled away, leaving nearly pure silver
This overstates the product of the Parkes process. After zinc is distilled off, the remaining retort metal still contains lead and other metals and is normally sent to cupellation for further refining.
Full reasoning
In the industrial Parkes process, removing zinc from the silver-rich crust does not directly leave “nearly pure silver.” A U.S. Department of Energy mining profile explains that after retorting, the remaining retort metal contains silver, gold, copper, and lead and is sent to a cupel furnace for additional refining. Only after cupellation is a silver/gold alloy (doré) produced.
The NCBI Bookshelf description of primary lead refining is consistent with this: Parkes removes silver and gold by transferring them into zinc, and later steps are still required to remove zinc and other remaining impurities. So the article skips important refining stages and describes the intermediate product as much purer than it actually is.
2 sources
- Energy and Environmental Profile of the U.S. Mining Industry: Lead and Zinc
The enriched silver/zinc alloy ... is subjected to a distillation process for zinc removal... The retort metal (containing silver, gold, copper, and lead) is sent to a cupel furnace for additional refining... After cupellation, the silver/gold alloy commonly known as doré is cast and sold.
- Inorganic and Organic Lead Compounds | NCBI Bookshelf
The removal of the precious metals by the Parkes process is based on the fact that they are more soluble in zinc than in lead... (iii) Removal of zinc ... (iv) Removal of bismuth...