en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohan_Kumar_(serial_killer)
2 corrections found
Upon his arrest in 2009, he was put on trial for two years before being convicted and sentenced to death for the murder of Anitha in 2013.
The timeline is wrong: Mohan Kumar was arrested on October 21, 2009, but Anitha-case proceedings began in late 2011 and he was convicted in December 2013—about four years after arrest, not two.
Full reasoning
Contemporary court reporting contradicts the article's "two years" timeline.
- Daijiworld's December 17, 2013 report says Mohan was convicted in Anitha's case "Four years after his arrest".
- The same report states that "The initial questioning in the case had commenced on November 21, 2011 ... and it had continued for about a year." That means the trial activity described there began in late 2011, not immediately upon arrest in 2009.
- The Karnataka High Court judgment in The Registrar General vs Mohan Kumar records that the trial-court conviction/order was dated 17/21.12.2013 in S.C. No. 96 of 2010.
So the article's statement that he was "put on trial for two years" after his 2009 arrest is inaccurate. The arrest-to-conviction gap was about four years, and the trial proceedings referenced in reporting began in November 2011 and continued for about a year before the December 2013 conviction.
2 sources
- Mangalore: Court convicts serial killer Cyanide Mohan - Daijiworld.com
Four years after his arrest, serial killer Mohan Kumar ... was on Tuesday December 17 convicted in one of the several cases of murder... The initial questioning in the case had commenced on November 21, 2011 in the then fast track court and it had continued for about a year.
- The Registrar General vs Mohan Kumar @ Sundar Rai @ Ananda @ on 12 October, 2017
... passed by the IV Additional Sessions Judge, Dakshina Kannada, Mangaluru, by the judgment of conviction dated 17/21.12.2013 in S.C.No.96 of 2010 ...
A Mangalore fast-track court tried and convicted him for the murder of 20 women in Karnataka from 2003 to 2009.
This overstates the role of a single fast-track court. Mohan Kumar's convictions were delivered by multiple courts over several years, including the Fourth and Sixth Additional District and Sessions Courts; the 20th case was decided in 2020, not by one fast-track court.
Full reasoning
The article incorrectly suggests that one Mangalore fast-track court tried and convicted Mohan Kumar in all 20 murder cases.
The record shows a more complicated procedural history:
- A 2018 Times of India report lays out the case timeline: 13 cases were shifted to the fast-track court in January 2011, but all 20 cases were later shifted to the Fourth Additional District and Sessions Court in June 2013.
- That same report says the first three convictions were delivered on December 17–18, 2013, and later cases were handled by the Sixth Additional District and Sessions Court.
- A June 2020 Times of India report states that the 20th and last case was decided by the sixth additional district and sessions court judge Sayeedunnisa.
- A 2013 Daijiworld report likewise identifies the court that convicted him in the early cases as the Fourth Additional District and Sessions Court, not simply a fast-track court that convicted him in all 20 murders.
So the problem is not whether he was eventually convicted in 20 murder cases, but the claim that a single Mangalore fast-track court tried and convicted him for all 20. The convictions came from different courts over multiple years.
3 sources
- Cyanide Mohan gets life term in fifth case | Mangaluru News - Times of India
Timeline: January, 2011: 13 cases shifted from other courts to FT Court. ... June 2013: All 20 cases shifted to fourth additional district and sessions court ... September 13, 2017: In fourth case, sixth additional district and sessions court finds Mohan guilty ...
- Serial killer Cyanide Mohan convicted in 20th case | Mangaluru News - Times of India
The sixth additional district and sessions court judge Sayeedunnisa on Saturday held serial killer Cyanide Mohan ... guilty ... This is the 20th and the last case to be tried in this court.
- Mangalore: Court convicts serial killer Cyanide Mohan - Daijiworld.com
The fourth additional district and sessions court on Tuesday December 17 convicted Mohan Kumar ... in one of the several cases of murder ... On Wednesday December 18 [it] convicted Mohan Kumar ... in a third case.