en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jethro_Tull_(band)
1 correction found
Jethro Tull became only the second rock band after The Beatles to perform at Carnegie Hall in New York City.
This is incorrect. Carnegie Hall’s own archives show multiple rock acts had played there before Jethro Tull, including the Rolling Stones in 1964, and Carnegie Hall records many rock events before Tull’s November 4, 1970 appearance.
Full reasoning
Carnegie Hall’s own historical materials contradict this claim.
- Carnegie Hall’s Data Lab says that after the Beatles and the Rolling Stones appeared there in 1964, the Hall saw a growing number of rock events: 1 in 1967–68, 4 in 1968–69, 13 in 1969–70, and 38 in 1970–71.
- Carnegie Hall’s collections page for Jethro Tull places the band’s Carnegie Hall performance on November 4, 1970.
If Jethro Tull played Carnegie Hall in the 1970–71 season, and Carnegie Hall records 13 rock events in 1969–70 plus the Beatles and Rolling Stones earlier, then Jethro Tull were plainly not the second rock band to perform there.
Carnegie Hall has also published a rock-history page listing earlier rock debuts at the venue, including The Byrds (September 26, 1969) and Led Zeppelin (October 17, 1969), both before Jethro Tull’s November 1970 show. So the statement is contradicted by Carnegie Hall’s own archive and historical writeups.
3 sources
- Carnegie Hall's Rock Explosion of 1971-72 | Carnegie Hall Data Lab
The years following the 1964 appearances by the Beatles and Rolling Stones showed steady yearly increases in the number of rock events at Carnegie Hall, from one in 1967-68, four in 1968-69, and 13 in 1969-70. But even given a jump to 38 events in 1970-71...
- Carnegie Hall - Search Result
Event: Jethro Tull, Rock Band 1970-1971 Main Hall Wednesday, November 4, 1970 at 8:30PM
- Rock ’n’ Roll at Carnegie Hall | Carnegie Hall
Here are just some of the rock and pop artists who have made their Carnegie Hall debuts... The Byrds (September 26, 1969), Led Zeppelin (October 17, 1969), Steppenwolf (December 6, 1969), James Taylor (June 12, 1970), Jethro Tull (November 4, 1970).