blog.interceptfund.com/p/ending-respiratory-infections
1 correction found
account for around 7% of deaths from major causes in the U.S.
This overstates what the cited U.S. mortality data show. The Our World in Data source used for “respiratory infections” includes COVID-19 and tuberculosis, so it is not a measure of the common respiratory infections discussed here.
Full reasoning
The article is discussing common respiratory infections like colds and influenza, but the cited U.S. mortality figure is not drawn from a category limited to those illnesses.
- The Our World in Data series cited for respiratory infections explicitly says the measure includes tuberculosis and COVID-19 and reports deaths from respiratory infections and tuberculosis. That is a much broader category than the common respiratory viral infections discussed in the paragraph.
- Official NCHS/CDC leading-cause-of-death data for 2023 show that COVID-19 accounted for 1.6% of all U.S. deaths, while influenza and pneumonia were not even in the overall top 10 causes of death. So a statement that the common respiratory infections under discussion account for “around 7%” of major-cause deaths is not an apples-to-apples use of the underlying data.
In other words, the problem is not that respiratory infections are unimportant; it is that the 7% number comes from a broader bucket that includes diseases outside the scope of the claim, especially COVID-19 and tuberculosis.
3 sources
- Death rate from respiratory infections | Our World in Data
The estimated death rate from respiratory infections, including tuberculosis and COVID-19, per 100,000 people.
- Deaths from respiratory infections, 2023 | Our World in Data
Sort by: Total number of deaths from respiratory infections and tuberculosis, 2023.
- Deaths: Leading Causes for 2023 - National Vital Statistics Reports
Number of deaths and percentage of total deaths for the 10 leading causes of death: United States, 2022 and 2023 ... COVID-19 49,932 1.6 ... Influenza and pneumonia was not among the overall top 10 causes in Table C.