en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herod_Antipas
2 corrections found
placing votive shields in the Antonia palace at Jerusalem
Philo's account places Pilate's shields in Herod's palace in Jerusalem, not in the Antonia.
Full reasoning
The location given here is wrong.
Our main ancient source for the shields incident is Philo of Alexandria, who says Pilate "dedicated some gilt shields in the palace of Herod, in the holy city." Secondary reference works summarizing Philo likewise state that Pilate hung the shields in Herod's palace in Jerusalem.
So the problem is not that the shields incident never happened; it is that this article places it in the Antonia palace/fortress rather than Herod's palace.
2 sources
- Philo of Alexandria, On the Embassy to Gaius
He ... dedicated some gilt shields in the palace of Herod, in the holy city.
- Encyclopedia.com: Pontius Pilate
When he hung votive shields inscribed with the emperor's name in Herod's palace in Jerusalem, Herod's four sons protested to Tiberius, who ordered the shields to be taken to a temple in Caesarea.
In Journey to Bethlehem, he is portrayed as the semi-loyal son of Herod and struggles to follow his father's commands.
The film *Journey to Bethlehem* features Herod’s son Antipater, not Herod Antipas.
Full reasoning
This sentence attributes the role in Journey to Bethlehem to Herod Antipas, but the film's character is Antipater.
The movie's official cast page lists Joel Smallbone as Antipater, while Antonio Banderas plays Herod. A contemporary review likewise describes the film as centering partly on Herod's conflicted son, Antipater, and says Herod commands Antipater to track down the prophesied child.
So the film is not portraying Herod Antipas as Herod's semi-loyal son in the Nativity story; it is portraying Antipater, a different son of Herod the Great.
2 sources
- Journey To Bethlehem - Cast
JOEL SMALLBONE Antipater ... ANTONIO BANDERAS Herod
- Common Sense Media: Journey to Bethlehem review
the jealous and vindictive King Herod (Antonio Banderas); and Herod's conflicted son, Antipater (Joel Smallbone).